Susan Hufford, 53, Sharon Hufford, 74, killed, Randolph Hufford, 54, Donald Hufford, 74, seriously injured, taken to hospital, after their car is rear-ended on Highway 12 in Santa Rosa, by a pickup driven by Nicholas Lee Tognozzi, 30, who was arrested.

March 16, 2014

Two Santa Rosa women on their way to dinner with their husbands were killed Saturday evening by a suspected drunken driver when his pickup rear-ended the sedan they were riding in as it sat in traffic on Highway 12 near Farmers Lane.

Susan Hufford, 53, and her mother-in-law, Sharon Hufford, 74, were riding in the rear of the Toyota Camry driven by Randolph Hufford, 54, with his father Donald Hufford, 74, in the front passenger's seat when it was struck from behind by a full-sized GMC Sierra pickup, CHP Sgt. Erik Egide said.

The women were killed instantly by the impact. The deaths mean Randolph Hufford lost his mother and wife in the accident, while Donald Hufford lost his wife and daughter-in-law.

“It's brutal. Just a tragedy,” Egide said.

The pickup showed no sign of braking and struck the sedan with such force that it pushed it forward 40 to 50 feet and completely crumpled the trunk and rear seat of the vehicle, Egide said. Eastbound Highway 12 was closed for several hours Saturday evening as emergency personnel swarmed the scene.

The driver of the pickup, 30-year-old Nicholas Lee Tognozzi of Rohnert Park, was arrested on suspicion of vehicular manslaughter and driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs, Egide said. He also is suspected of using his cellphone at the time of the accident, Egide said.

The accident occurred around 5:20 p.m. in an area where eastbound traffic on Highway 12 often backs up several hundred feet west of the Farmers Lane intersection. Fast-moving eastbound drivers often have to brake to avoid crashing into stopped traffic there.

The Camry was stopped in the left lane of Highway 12 a few hundred feet west of Farmers Lane, just before it widens into four lanes. The pickup was traveling at 55 to 65 mph when it collided with the Camry, Egide said. The impact pushed the Camry into a third vehicle, a Suzuki occupied by a couple who were not injured.

Witness Sara Rogers passed the scene of the crash moments after it occurred and said the pickup was on top of the sedan. She said several vehicles pulled over and people appeared to be trying to help the victims.

“I drive with my kids in the back seat all the time,” Rogers said later as she surveyed the scene from an office complex overlooking the closed highway. “It's scary.”

Santa Rosa firefighters who responded to the scene used the Jaws of Life during the rescue effort. The father and son were transported to Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital with moderate and major injuries.

CHP officers and Santa Rosa police diverted traffic from the highway at the Sonoma County Fairgrounds exit, down Bennett Valley Road to Farmers Lane.

Tognozzi's Facebook page indicates he is a 2002 graduate of Analy High School and works as a solar panel installer at a company in Novato.

People Involved: 
Susan Hufford
Sharon Hufford
Randolph Hufford
Donald Hufford
Nicholas Lee Tognozzi
Highway 12 Eastbound
Sonoma Co.

Leave a Comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.


I am a distant friend knowing the Hufford Family through a former next door neighbor of mine In San Jose, Shirley Hufford-Moody. I had met Sharon only once or twice but very much liked her and her husband Don. Wonderful, loving family. My heart goes out to the Hufford family over this tragic, unnecessary loss by a distracted driver who should not have been on the road. Shame on you, young man. You will have this on your mind the rest of your life. Enough said.

More reports from our archive:

November 20, 2013

Two women were injured Wednesday morning in a crash on state Highway 500 that police say was caused by tailgating.

December 2, 2013

A Virginia man died of injuries from a car crash Tuesday after his car collided with another vehicle Monday morning in Manassas.

November 18, 2013

A rear-end crash on Lewisville Highway in north Clark County this morning sent a La Center woman to the hospital as a precautionary measure, according to Washington State Patrol.
Sandra Huffman, 24, of Amboy was driving a Nissan Maxima north on the highway when she crashed into the back of a Oldsmobile Aurora, also traveling north, said Trooper Will Finn.

January 22, 2014

Two Los Angeles police officers are recovering after a suspected drunken driver crashed into them, then sped away from the scene.

Investigators say the officers were traveling northbound on Vermont Avenue, just south of 74th Street, when they were rear-ended by a white BMW around 11:30 p.m. Tuesday.

November 22, 2013

hree people were ejected from their horse-drawn buggy after it was rear-ended by a vehicle, police said.

The buggy was traveling east on Fawn River Road west of S. Centreville Road in Sturgis Township in St. Joseph County around 3:30 p.m. Thursday.

January 19, 2014

A 32-year-old St. Augustine man was killed in a crash in Putnam County early Sunday morning, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.

Around 5:25 a.m. Sunday morning, troopers say Scott Stinson was driving south in the outside lane of State Road 207.

A log truck had completed a right turn from Stone Road onto SR-207 before the crash occurred.

April 26, 2014

Part of Vashon Highway was blocked Saturday afternoon after a fatal collision between a car and a motorcycle.

The collision happened at about 4:30 p.m. The King County Sheriff’s Office said the motorcyclist was stopped and waiting to make a left turn and was rear-ended by a vehicle.

Investigators had to take a ferry to reach the scene. Ferry traffic was delayed.